Don't Hire a Dog Trainer to Train Your Dog Unless You Read This! 2023

Don't Hire a Dog Trainer to Train Your Dog Unless You Read This! 2023

When we first brought Westin into our lives, he was...well...a bit of a menace. He has always been a good dog—I believe all dogs are inherently good—but he was far from obedient. No, obedience is something that all dogs have to learn.

And if we're being honest, it's more difficult for some dogs than others. In our experience, it wasn't long before we started thinking about hiring a certified dog trainer. But it was quite a while before we actually went for it.


Why So Many People Try to Train Their Own Dogs

A dog during a training class.

It's easy to watch a few episodes of a dog training show or read a few chapters of a book and think you can handle the job. Reality is quite different, and that's something we learned the hard way. Westin came to us at a time when we had to be a little mindful of our spending, and we weren't exactly eager to invest in what we thought would be expensive obedience training.

So we bought a few books with up-to-date information, DVR'd a few episodes of The Dog Whisperer and tried to get in some hands-on experience with our less-than-advanced skills. That is until we realized that Westin was six months old and still gnawing at the couch as if he's got separation anxiety.

The allure of the DIY approach to dog training was just too good to ignore—until we figured out his problem behaviors were not going away. Westin definitely needed a professional trainer (preferably certified by the Certification Council of Professional Dog Trainers) to help him get on the right track.


The Risks of Passing Up On Dog Trainers

A dog going through a training program.

The biggest drawback of do-it-yourself dog training is the potential lost time. If you are among the small percentage who can successfully train your dog without help or intervention, you don't have to worry about lost time.

However, if you're fumbling through as you go along, you stand to lose valuable moments in your dog's life that could be spent sending mixed and inconsistent messages. Yet again, we learned this the hard way. Our private training sessions weren't working at all!

Westin was a pup when we started training. We gave it six months before we decided that what we were doing wasn't working. By that time, he was almost a year old and had made some strong habits out of his bad behaviors, even though we thought we were working to correct them.

Just like with humans, the first year of a dog's life is extremely formative. It's not that you can't teach an old dog new tricks. It's just that it's not as easy to train them. My advice to anyone with a new pooch is to hire the services of an in-person dog trainer sooner rather than later.

If you have dog training experience—with the knowledge of learning theory, operant conditioning, and techniques—then go for it. Otherwise, bite the bullet and hire a dog trainer for a program or course. You'll be glad you did when you see your pooch flaunt his trained skills. But it's crucial to zero in on legitimate dog trainers, too! Let me explain...



The Danger of Hiring an Amateur (and Not a Professional Dog Trainer)

The wrong training will teach animals in a counterproductive way.

Do you know someone who claims to be a dog trainer? Maybe they'll train your dog for free or give you a discount for private lessons or even group classes. There aren't many situations in which this works out.

It is imperative that you find the right one for your dog—and that isn't always a family friend or relative. Dog training is not something you should leave up to chance. When you hire someone you know to train dogs, you're less likely to ask hard questions because you don't want to offend them.

Case in point: service dog training and therapy dogs. Are their development techniques compassionate and safe for health? Do they use choke collars? You would assume they wouldn't and asking could be offensive, right? Well, what if they do and you didn't ask?


Learning About Different Types of Professional Dog Trainers

Pet "students" can choose a specific "program" or "school" of training.

When we set out on our journey to find a trainer for Westin, we thought it would be as easy as Googling the closest dog training professionals and comparing prices. Boy, were we wrong! How many different methods and schools of thought could there be?

Surprisingly, there are many different methods and types of dog trainers. They can provide anything from private training to obedience and behavioral courses. While the cost and courses vary, they are all aimed at providing students (and owners of pets) the value of practice and hard work. Below are the basic categories of dog training you'll have to choose from:



Behavioral dog training or program.

This is the most basic and common type of dog training that is done. Behavioral dog training addresses issues like chewing, barking, and housebreaking. It's best done when they're still puppies, too. This is what we started Westin on, but then we moved on to obedience training once he shed his disruptive behaviors.



Obedience dog training or program.

With professional help, it wasn't long before Westin was ready to get started on obedience dog training. We were able to use the same dog trainer. Here, he learned to obey common commands like sit, stay, lie down, and rollover. These commands are more than just parlor tricks. When a dog learns to sit and come on command, you can use them to keep him out of tricky or dangerous situations.



Agility dog training or program.

Agility training takes obedience training to another level. Agility training teaches dogs to participate in sports, obstacle courses, and jumping. This is actually an integral part when you're looking to train service dogs. It basically combines physical strength and skill. Having a reliable joint and hip support product is a must in this program.



Vocational dog training or program.

Working dogs that are meant to herd, hunt, do rescue work, or become service dogs all must go through vocational training. If this is what you want for your dog, you will need to find a trainer who specializes in the course or skills so they can begin learning and understanding effectively.

All dog trainers fall into one of two categories: “Do” and “Don't.” Many certified dog trainers believe that the key to training lies in rewarding good behaviors instead of punishing pets for bad ones. These are “Do”-based certified trainers. “Don't”-based trainers do the opposite.


Do-based training

  • Lure-Reward Training – Enticing dogs or puppies by rewarding good behavior with a food lure (or treat).

  • Compulsion-Praise Training – Physically manipulating the dog to perform your requested task (e.g. sitting), and then rewarding it with a treat.

  • Marker Training – Using a sound aid or clicks along with rewards to let your dog know which behaviors you desire.

Don't-based training

  • Replacement Training – Correcting undesirable behavior with a more desirable one.

  • Consequence Training– Employ an undesirable consequence to the dog when he performs an undesirable act. A choke collar is one example of consequence training, but it isn't the only one. Consequence training could also mean taking away attention or affection whenever the dog performs an undesirable behavior.


How to Know Which Trainer is Right For You

The right dog training program need the right trainer.

Now that you know about all the various types of trainers and training methods, it's up to you to decide which is right for your dog. If you're unsure, schedule a meeting with a few different trainers and discuss their methods and your options.

You should get a pretty good feel for which method is right for you by your comfort level with the training. And remember that you will have to perform the tasks at home. Every trainer will give you some homework. So be sure you're comfortable with the method before you invest in training.


Pros and Cons of Professional Dog Training

Pros and cons of dog training for clients.

First, let's start with what's easy. The “con” of hiring a dog trainer is the cost. That's the elephant in the room, isn't it? But when you start to really examine the pros, you'll realize that you're getting so much more than just obedience.

You'll learn how to spend quality time with your dog and avoid the frustrations of misunderstanding one another. He'll know what you want from him and you'll know how to get it out of him. In many cases, trainers will also socialize your dog for you.

This is something that requires work on your end, too, of course. However, it certainly helps to give your dog professionally supervised time with all kinds of other breeds. This is the biggest reason why knowledge and certification are a must when looking for dog trainers. Access to veterans of the industry can be tricky!


Why Personality Matters

The personality of a dog trainer is a crucial factor for his "students."

We absolutely love Westin's trainer and I think that has helped a great deal with his training. I have always felt comfortable asking questions and requesting more time on something if he seems to need more work.

Our relationship with our dog's trainer is a true partnership, which is exactly the way it should be. If you don't like your dog's trainer, move on to the next. Not doing so can result in some negative consequences in the long run.


Questions to Ask a Potential Trainer

The questions would-be clients need to ask potential dog trainers.

Before you hire any professional for dog training, you should know exactly what to expect. I've compiled a list of the questions we asked potential trainers when we were interviewing for Westin. You may be able to think of a few more, but this is a good starting point:

  1. How long have you been training dogs?

  2. Have you ever trained this breed before?

  3. What type of equipment do you use and will I have to buy anything?

  4. Can you explain your training method? What happens when the dog performs an undesirable behavior?

  5. Do you guarantee any results?

  6. How will you know if my dog is stressed during training, and what will you do about it?


We hope this article on dog training will help you find the right trainer for your dog's needs. Dogs are easy to teach, but they can be pretty stubborn students, too! Remember, it will be a journey that you will take alongside your pet, so it's one you should enjoy as well. And don't hesitate to contact us if you'd like to get in touch with certified pet homeopathy experts.

Denyse Lessard
Denyse Lessard

21 Responses


April 10, 2023

Nice scare tactics. I trained two of my dogs and got compliments everywhere I went for her stellar behavior. At least try to not sound biased. 🤦🏻‍♂️

Anna Collins
Anna Collins

April 25, 2022

Thanks for mentioning how it would be beneficial to get dog training as early as possible since the first year of a dog’s life is extremely formative and they might make a habit out of bad behaviors if not reinforced with good ones properly. We just got a Golden Retriever puppy quite recently, but we don’t know much about dog training to do it by ourselves. Hopefully, we’ll be able to find dog training services within the area that might be able to help us.


July 26, 2021

Hi Anthony,

Thank you for your comment. I hope this article has proven helpful to find a trainer to best suit your needs.



July 26, 2021

I’m living in nyc lm look for a trainer to train my dog to protect my family from danger while walking the streets


June 21, 2021

Choke chains of slip chains are not inherently bad. It is obviously bad to use them incorrectly, but a good trainer will know how to use these tools without harming a dog. Letting a dog pull on a flat buckle collar can damage a dog’s trachea over time, and putting a dog in a harness encourages pulling. The best thing for dogs is to learn to walk nicely on a leash. Slip chains, and pinch collars should be used on a dog that is relatively insensitive to pressure on their neck. The leash pressure and corrections applied with these collars are actually significantly less likely to cause damage than allowing a dog to pull on a collar for years. If a dog is food or toy motivated, these things can and should be used to motivate the dog. The rewards show the dog why they should want to do the behavior, and the collar shows the dog that the behavior is still necessary when the environment out-competes the rewards.


February 08, 2021

Great article. My daughter is interested in getting a dog and wants to train it. I agree with you that you should train your own dog. What would you say is the main concern when starting training? I enjoyed and learned a lot from your post and will be returning. Thank you. Take care.


February 02, 2021

This post was far better than most “how to choose a dog trainer” articles, but I strongly disagree with you saying there are “do” and “don’t” trainers… You should never hire either a “do” or a “don’t” because if the person is one or the other then it tells you they have a limited understanding of what they are doing and therefore, a limited ability to help your dog. The best trainers combine all of the subcategories listed under both “do” and “don’t” to create a customized approach for each individual dog and family. Dogs vary widely in their motivations, personality, drive, desire to please humans, etc. Families vary widely in their desire and ability to “read” their dog, willingness to invest time in learning how to speak Dog, and their ability to be consistent in their training. A family with several children and a spouse who thinks training is a waste of time may benefit from sending their dog to a program that creates habitual good behaviors that they can easily reinforce at home. A young couple or single person may have the time, ability and desire to invest in learning the intricacies of dog language and want to build the deepest, strongest relationship possible with their dog. They will benefit greatly from a balanced training approach that teaches them how to communicate with their dog on a deep level and surpass the need for any kind of external reinforcement due to their strong bond. That requires 1:1 study with a highly experienced trainer who does both on and off leash work. Then, there are a million other situations besides these two specific cases. A very good trainer uses many different tools, approaches and training techniques to best suit each individual circumstance. So both the dog and the rest of their family can be as successful as possible. If a trainer says something like, “I am a so-called ‘pure positive’ trainer” or a “dominance-based Alpha trainer” or “an e-collar trainer” or “a clicker trainer” KEEP SEARCHING because every one of those trainers is working with a limited toolbox that only applies to a small portion of the training and relationship-building process and none of them will be able to help you achemieve all that you and your dog are capable of. A trainer who says they tailor their approach to each individual circumstance and is familiar with and uses a variety of approaches during training based on what is most appropriate for the stage of training you are in and the abilities, interest level and desire of all participants in the process (dog included) with a heavy emphasis on building an intrinsically rewarding relationship between all parties (not a transactional or quid-pro-quo relationship, which is quite shallow) then you have a much greater chance of success. Best wishes!!


November 16, 2020

That was an interesting post.


September 14, 2020

Thank you so much. This article was a balm to my guilt. We have a 4 month old Shih-Poo who is one of the most intelligent dogs we ever owned. Her eyes were just seething with it at 8 weeks and still are. Laser focused on our face when we are talking to her or moving around. She’s eager to please and is a perfect dog to train. And she started to train so fast, even overnight when we potty trained her with a bell. She knows to ring it. And does.

But she has developed an independence and stubbornness, and picks and chooses when she wants to obey the “come” command, which is far less every day. And she relieves herself in the house, not always because we didn’t hear her ring the bell either. As a puppy she’s a chewer and biter of course, but she could win records over those. She knows “kisses” means to not bite our hand or fingers, and she adorably growls every time we remind her, while she tries to get a smaller nip in anyway. It’s a non-stop, all-day job to be aware of her chewing and redirect. And therein lies my guilt. Because I don’t have the time or the focus.

We didn’t buy the dog. Our college son did to ease his pain and anxiety over our 14 yr old Shih-Poo getting closer to the end of life. He can’t handle it. And she has been so lonely after losing her 14-yr long companion when our Havanese passed away two years ago. He wanted to give her a new friend as well as create a bond for him that would be there once she passed on. You don’t see 22 year old boys cry often, and it’s authentic when you do. We told him the expenses were his and he must train her, or at least start a program before returning to school in the fall, and we would take care of her while he was away. That did not happen, at all. And the burden falls to me. And I’m not capable at this point in my life, both physically or emotionally.

So I came to the internet to see if there were people who trained dogs for others yet. The last time I asked that question I was publicly scoffed at and told I had no business owning a dog if I had to even ask, as it’s no different than kids. If I made the choice I need to grow up and be responsible, regardless that I was 40 at the time. Needless to say that is why I was overwhelmed with guilt today.

Then I found your article and it so eloquently explained my predicament. It opened a shade to sunshine. I’m going to immediately start interviewing and hope for finding someone as well fitted as you did.


August 03, 2020

Reading something ought to be in hands on with a dog is 2 different things


June 29, 2020

That was an interesting post, Denyse. In my 10 years as a certified trainer, there’s ONE BIG LESSON I have learned. More intelligent dogs are better behaved. A More intelligent dog takes commands easier and understands what you need from them. The good news is no matter how clever you think your dog is.

You can unlock their hidden intelligence quickly and easily. If you guys are interested in brain training for Dogs course, please email me at

It’s great for eliminating any bad behaviors by tapping into your dog’s hidden intelligence.


June 01, 2020

Hey there!! Thanks for your comment and concerns about going to a trainer. You have nothing to fear as a good dog trainer will be a guide for YOU to train your dog. So in your dog’s eyes YOU will always be number 1!


June 01, 2020

Will my dog favour my trainer over me?I sound entitled but its my first time getting a dog and Im really nervous

El Troco
El Troco

May 11, 2020

Can a dog trainer guarantee the dog is going to be train? Yes, but only if the client buy a board and train package.
Is the client is expecting to have his/her dog trained with one hour a week session? they better follow the trainer instructions during the week, dogs learn by repetition the owner must work his/her dog 2 times a day a least for 10 minutes if the client hires a dog trainer and expect to have a train dog without doing their homework, they are just burning their money.

Puppy Training
Puppy Training

March 17, 2020

Dog training our goal is to teach you the skills to have a well behaved dog that is welcomed everywhere as well as enjoyed by all.


February 27, 2020

If you would likke to grow your experience only keep visiing this website and be updated with the
hottest information posted here.

Feel free to visit myy blog post :: puppy training near me

Dog training
Dog training

February 27, 2020

This is an incredible rousing article. I am essentially satisfied with your great training process. Consistency are key to successful obedience training. Exact and liberal rewards are critical to dog training. And it is essential that you devote time to training on a routine basis until you are seeing the behaviors you want.


January 06, 2020

Valuable info. Lucky me I discovered your web site accidentally,
and I’m shocked why this accident didn’t took plae earlier!

Ibookmarked it.

my blog: puppy classes near me


August 27, 2019

whoah this blog is great i really like studying your posts.
Stay up the good work! You recognize, lots of
people are hunting around supplies for reptiles this info, you can help them greatly.

Karl Beatty
Karl Beatty

March 29, 2019

I really enjoyed this article. As a trainer myself, I found it to be easy to understand for the everyday pet parent, rather than full of the confusing “trainer speak” that usually explains training to people. Thank you for this..I’ll be sharing!


April 18, 2019

I do not even know the way I stopped up right here,
but I thought this publish was good. I do not realize who you might be but certainly you’re going to a famous blogger if you happen how to train a puppy are not already.

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.